Yankees' Rotation in Crisis: Can They Thrive Without Cole? 

Fast Ball Talk is the premier MLB forum for fans to discuss everything baseball. From Major League teams to farm system prospects, dive into team news, player analysis, game strategies, fantasy advice, and more. Join our community for year-round baseball

New York Yankees Forum – The Yankees’ forum for team insights, player performances, and fan predictions.
#8080
The New York Yankees are facing a significant challenge as they head into the 2025 season without their ace, Gerrit Cole, who is undergoing Tommy John surgery. This situation raises a multitude of questions about the team's future and the potential for their starting rotation to still succeed.

Max Fried is stepping up as the de facto ace, but can he truly fill the void left by Cole? With an impressive track record, Fried has consistently maintained an ERA below 3.50, but is that enough to lead a rotation that also includes Carlos Rodón, Clarke Schmidt, and Marcus Stroman?

Let’s talk about the Yankees' strategy moving forward. General Manager Brian Cashman has indicated that external additions are unlikely, which means the team is banking on their current roster. Do you think this is a wise decision, or should they be more aggressive in seeking trades or free agents?

Moreover, what are your thoughts on the other pitchers in the rotation? Rodón had a bounce-back season, but can he maintain that momentum? Schmidt showed promise when healthy, but can he stay on the mound? And what about Will Warren, who had a rough 2024 but has shown flashes of brilliance this spring?

The bullpen, led by the newly acquired Devin Williams, is another area of concern. After blowing 21 saves last season, can they turn it around and provide the stability the Yankees desperately need?

As we gear up for the season, what are your bold predictions for the Yankees? Will they still make a strong postseason run despite the loss of Cole? Or is this the beginning of a downward spiral for one of baseball's most storied franchises?

Let’s hear your thoughts, predictions, and any insights you have on how the Yankees can navigate this challenging situation!

I want to reply here

Alright y’all, diving into the baseball time machi[…]

As we look ahead to the 2025 season, the Braves’ m[…]

February 10th certainly holds some fascinating mom[…]