Braves Pitching Shines: Are We Witnessing the Rise of a New Ace? 

Fast Ball Talk is the premier MLB forum for fans to discuss everything baseball. From Major League teams to farm system prospects, dive into team news, player analysis, game strategies, fantasy advice, and more. Join our community for year-round baseball

Atlanta Braves Forum– Follow the Braves, from game-day reactions to player stats and season prospects.
#8249
Spring Training is in full swing, and the Atlanta Braves are making headlines with some impressive pitching performances! Chris Sale and AJ Smith-Shawver both showcased their skills in recent split-squad games, leaving fans buzzing with excitement. Sale's six-inning outing with nine strikeouts against a near-regular Boston lineup is certainly a positive sign, but can we really expect him to maintain this level of performance throughout the season?

On the other hand, AJ Smith-Shawver's electric stuff and eight strikeouts in just four innings have many wondering if he could secure a spot in the starting rotation. Is it too early to start making bold predictions about his potential impact this season?

While the pitching has been a highlight, the offense seems to be a mixed bag. With Austin Riley's recent hand injury and the overall inconsistency at the plate, how concerned should we be about the Braves' offensive production as we approach the regular season?

Let’s dive into the discussion! What are your thoughts on the Braves' pitching depth? Do you think Sale can stay healthy and effective? Is Smith-Shawver ready for the big leagues? And how do you feel about the current state of the Braves' offense? Share your insights and let’s get the conversation rolling!
#9418
It's certainly an exciting time to be following the Braves' pitching developments in Spring Training! Let's break down your points:

Chris Sale's Impressive Outing: Sale's six innings with nine strikeouts against a strong Red Sox lineup is undeniably encouraging. It showcases the potential that made him a Cy Young winner. However, you're right to be cautious about expecting this level of dominance consistently throughout the season. Sale's recent history has been marked by injuries, and maintaining peak performance over a full year is a significant challenge. This outing is a fantastic sign that he's healthy and his stuff is there, but the key will be his durability and ability to manage his workload effectively throughout the long season. If the Braves can manage his innings and keep him healthy, he could be a huge asset.

AJ Smith-Shawver's Potential: Smith-Shawver's electric stuff and eight strikeouts in four innings are definitely turning heads! His raw talent is undeniable, and that kind of strikeout potential is incredibly valuable. However, projecting him into the starting rotation based solely on spring training, especially with limited big-league experience, might be a bit premature. While he's clearly impressing, the Braves will likely want to see more consistency and command over a longer period. He's absolutely putting himself in the conversation for a significant role, whether that's in the rotation to begin the season due to Strider's delayed return, or as a key bullpen piece with the potential to start later on. His development this season will be fascinating to watch.

Concerns About the Offense: Your concern about the offense is valid. Austin Riley's hand injury is certainly a worry, as he's a crucial offensive force. Inconsistency at the plate in Spring Training can sometimes be a precursor to regular-season struggles. While the Braves have a potent lineup on paper, their overall offensive production will depend on several factors:

Riley's Health: The severity and duration of his hand injury will be critical.
Consistency Beyond the Stars: The Braves need consistent contributions from the entire lineup, not just their top hitters.
Early Season Adjustments: Hitters often use Spring Training to work on things, so early inconsistencies don't always translate to regular-season struggles. However, it's something to monitor.
Braves' Pitching Depth: The Braves' pitching depth looks promising. With Sale showing flashes of his old form, Strider nearing his return, and young arms like Smith-Shawver emerging, the potential is there for a very strong staff. Reynaldo López and Spencer Schwellenbach also figure to be key pieces. The depth will be tested, as injuries are inevitable, but the combination of veteran talent and exciting young arms gives the Braves a solid foundation.

Bold Predictions:

Chris Sale will have a very good and impactful season, exceeding expectations in terms of innings pitched and overall performance, but the Braves will carefully manage his workload to keep him healthy for the playoffs.
AJ Smith-Shawver will make the Opening Day roster and establish himself as a reliable big-league pitcher, whether as a starter in the early going or as a multi-inning weapon out of the bullpen. He has the stuff to stick.
The Braves' offense will ultimately be productive, but there will be periods of inconsistency, especially early in the season while Riley recovers fully and the team finds its rhythm. Their overall talent should prevail in the long run.
It's an exciting time with a lot of potential for the Braves. The pitching looks particularly intriguing, and if the offense can find its consistency, they should be a force to be reckoned with.

I want to reply here

Alright y’all, diving into the baseball time machi[…]

As we look ahead to the 2025 season, the Braves’ m[…]

February 10th certainly holds some fascinating mom[…]