Is 2025 Topps a Home Run or a Strikeout? Join the Debate! 

As we dive into the 2025 Topps baseball card season, it seems like collectors are already divided on the new designs. The return of foil has sparked a lot of frustration, with many feeling it detracts from the overall aesthetic and readability of the cards. Is this a case of nostalgia clouding our judgment, or is there a legitimate reason to be concerned about the direction Topps is taking?

What do you think about the design choices made this year? Are you a fan of the shiny foil, or do you agree that it complicates the viewing experience? Some collectors are reminiscing about the simplicity of past designs, particularly those from the '70s. Could we see a resurgence of interest in vintage styles as a reaction to the current trends?

Additionally, the mixed reviews on the Stars of MLB inserts have raised questions about their relevance. Are these inserts adding value to the set, or are they just taking up space?

Let’s also talk about the player selection. With some familiar names and a few rookies making their debut, how do you feel about the balance of established stars versus newcomers in this year's set?

Lastly, for those who have already gotten their hands on the new cards, what has been your experience? Any standout cards or surprises in your packs?

Join the conversation and share your thoughts on the 2025 Topps release!