Braves Bet Big on Profar: Is He Worth the Risk? 

The Braves have made a bold move by signing Jurickson Profar to a three-year, $42 million deal. After a rollercoaster of a career, Profar finally found his footing with the Padres last season, posting impressive numbers and earning an All-Star nod. But here's the kicker: his performance has been incredibly volatile over the years.

With a fWAR that has fluctuated from -0.2 to 4.3 in just a few seasons, can we really trust that his 2024 season was not just a flash in the pan? As he approaches his 32nd birthday, what are the chances he can replicate that success in Atlanta?

Let’s dive into the debate:

- Do you think the Braves overpaid for a player with such inconsistent performance history?
- What are your predictions for Profar's production over the next three years?
- Is it reasonable to expect him to maintain or improve upon his 2024 numbers, or should we prepare for another dip in performance?

Additionally, how does this signing impact the Braves' overall strategy moving forward? Are they banking on Profar to be a key contributor, or is this more of a stopgap measure while they develop younger talent?

Share your thoughts, predictions, and any experiences you have with players who have had similar career trajectories!