- Sun Nov 17, 2024 3:56 pm
#1297
As we dive into the offseason, the spotlight is on two intriguing pitchers: Max Scherzer and Walker Buehler. Both have had their share of ups and downs, but they present a fascinating contrast in terms of their potential value on the free-agent market.
Scherzer, a future Hall of Famer, has a track record that speaks for itself. However, his recent injury struggles raise questions about his durability and whether he can still be counted on as a frontline starter. At 41, can he defy the odds and deliver ace-level production once again? Or is he more likely to be a gamble that could leave teams disappointed?
On the other hand, Buehler, while younger and with a promising upside, has had his own battles with injuries, including two Tommy John surgeries. His 2024 season was a disaster, but he showed flashes of brilliance in the playoffs. Is he a risk worth taking, or does his recent performance suggest he might not return to form?
This brings us to the big question: If your team needed a bounce-back starter, who would you rather sign? Would you take the chance on Scherzer's experience and pedigree, or would you roll the dice on Buehler's potential for a comeback?
Let’s hear your thoughts! What factors would influence your decision? Are you more inclined to trust a veteran with a storied career, or do you believe in the upside of a younger pitcher trying to reclaim his spot? And what kind of contracts do you think each player deserves? Share your predictions and insights!
Scherzer, a future Hall of Famer, has a track record that speaks for itself. However, his recent injury struggles raise questions about his durability and whether he can still be counted on as a frontline starter. At 41, can he defy the odds and deliver ace-level production once again? Or is he more likely to be a gamble that could leave teams disappointed?
On the other hand, Buehler, while younger and with a promising upside, has had his own battles with injuries, including two Tommy John surgeries. His 2024 season was a disaster, but he showed flashes of brilliance in the playoffs. Is he a risk worth taking, or does his recent performance suggest he might not return to form?
This brings us to the big question: If your team needed a bounce-back starter, who would you rather sign? Would you take the chance on Scherzer's experience and pedigree, or would you roll the dice on Buehler's potential for a comeback?
Let’s hear your thoughts! What factors would influence your decision? Are you more inclined to trust a veteran with a storied career, or do you believe in the upside of a younger pitcher trying to reclaim his spot? And what kind of contracts do you think each player deserves? Share your predictions and insights!
- By Anonymous