Is Alexis Diaz's Closer Role in Jeopardy? Exploring the Reds' Bullpen Options! 

As we gear up for the 2025 Fantasy Baseball season, the closer situation in Cincinnati is heating up, and it’s sparking some serious debate among fantasy enthusiasts. Alexis Diaz, who was almost a lock for the closer role, is struggling this spring, raising questions about his reliability. With a concerning 5 ER in just 2.1 IP and a significant drop in his strikeout rate, many are wondering if he’ll even start the season in the majors.

This brings us to the intriguing question: if Diaz is out, who should the Reds turn to? Sam Moll has been a solid setup man but lacks closing experience. Tony Santillan boasts an impressive K/9 rate but has limited big-league innings. Scott Barlow has the experience but has struggled with consistency. And let’s not forget Emilio Pagan, who has had success in the past.

What do you think? Should the Reds take a chance on Santillan’s upside, or is it safer to go with the more experienced Barlow? Or could Moll surprise us all?

Additionally, how do you feel about drafting closers who are in uncertain situations? Are you willing to take the risk on Diaz, or do you prefer to play it safe with more established options?

Let’s hear your thoughts, bold predictions, and any experiences you’ve had with similar situations in your fantasy leagues!