Can the Pirates Turn Optimism into Wins in 2025? 

The Pirates are talking a big game about 2025. Optimism abounds, fueled by young talent and veteran leadership. But is this just spring training hype, or can they finally translate potential into performance? McCutchen’s comments about leaving wins on the table last season are particularly striking. Is a change in mentality enough to bridge that gap? How many wins do you realistically see them adding this year? Can they contend for a Wild Card spot, or are we looking at another season of development and near misses? The rotation gets a lot of attention, but what about the bullpen and the defense? Are there any under-the-radar players you think could be key to their success? Let’s hear your predictions and break down what needs to happen for the Pirates to truly turn the corner.