Can Pat Murphy Break the Second Season Curse for Brewers Managers? 

As we gear up for the 2025 MLB season, all eyes are on Pat Murphy and how he will navigate his second year as the manager of the Milwaukee Brewers. Historically, second seasons for Brewers managers have been a mixed bag, with many experiencing a decline in performance. For instance, Ron Roenicke and Phil Garner both faced significant drops in their second years, while only a handful managed to improve their win percentages slightly.

This leads us to a critical question: What does history tell us about the challenges Murphy might face in his second season? Given that he had a stellar first year, tied for the second-highest win total among Brewers managers, can he maintain that momentum? Or will he fall victim to the common trend of regression?

Moreover, with the potential departure of key players like Willy Adames, how much of an impact will roster changes have on the team's performance? Is it fair to place the burden of success solely on Murphy, or should we consider the broader context of team dynamics and player development?

Let’s dive deeper into this discussion. What are your predictions for Murphy's second season? Do you think he can defy the odds and improve upon his first-year success? Or will he face the same fate as many of his predecessors? Share your thoughts, experiences, and any insights you have on what makes a successful second season for a manager in the ever-evolving landscape of Major League Baseball.