Brewers Infield Dilemma: Can Unproven Prospects Rise to the Challenge? 

The Milwaukee Brewers are facing a pivotal moment as they prepare for the upcoming season, particularly in the infield. With the departure of Willy Adames and the recent signings of Paul DeJong and Brendan Rodgers, the team seems to be banking on internal options to fill the gaps. This raises some intriguing questions: Are the Brewers making a mistake by not pursuing a more experienced infielder?

Oliver Dunn, Caleb Durbin, and Andruw Monasterio are all vying for a starting role, but can any of them truly step up to the challenge? Dunn has shown flashes of potential but struggled with strikeouts last season. Durbin, on the other hand, has been compared to Jose Altuve, but can he live up to that hype? And what about Monasterio, who had a disappointing year?

Let’s not forget about the prospects like Mike Boeve and Cooper Pratt. Could one of them make a surprise impact this season? Or are we setting ourselves up for disappointment by relying on unproven talent?

I’m curious to hear your thoughts. Do you believe the Brewers are taking a gamble that could pay off, or are they setting themselves up for failure? What are your bold predictions for the infield this season? Will we see a breakout performance from one of these players, or will the lack of a veteran presence haunt the team?

Let’s dive into this discussion and explore the potential outcomes for the Brewers' infield in 2025!