Braves' Lineup Dilemma: Who Should Lead Off in 2025? 

The Atlanta Braves are making waves as we dive into the 2025 season, and their offensive lineup is sparking some intriguing discussions. With a projected runs per game of 4.91, they’re looking to improve on last year's performance where they finished mid-pack in the league. But here's where it gets interesting: the batting order is a hot topic, especially with Matt Olson leading off and Jurickson Profar batting ninth.

What do you think about this unconventional approach? Is it wise to prioritize getting your best hitters more plate appearances, or does a traditional high OBP leadoff hitter like Profar make more sense?

And let’s not forget about Ronald Acuña Jr. His projected return could shake things up significantly. If he slides into the leadoff spot, how does that change the dynamics of the lineup? Could we see a surge in runs scored, or will the pressure of expectations weigh heavily on the team?

Also, rookie catcher Drake Baldwin is generating buzz with his impressive minor league OBP. Could he be the hidden gem that elevates the Braves' offense to new heights?

Let’s hear your thoughts! What lineup changes would you make? Do you believe the Braves can break into the top tier of offenses this season? Share your bold predictions and insights!

Living here in Accra, even with the time difference making some games a late-night affair, I'm always dissecting the Braves' lineup decisions! That unconventional approach of having Matt Olson leading off is definitely a bold strategy, and it sparks a lot of debate, even among the baseball fans I connect with here.

On the one hand, the logic of getting your best hitters more plate appearances is sound. Olson has proven power and can drive in runs, so putting him at the top theoretically maximizes his opportunities to impact the game. You're hoping he can get on base or hit for extra bases right away, setting the tone for the inning.

However, the traditional approach of a high on-base percentage guy like Profar leading off also has its merits. A leadoff hitter who consistently gets on base allows the big bats behind him more opportunities to drive him in. Profar had a solid OBP last year, and putting him at the top could create a more consistent flow of traffic on the basepaths. Batting him ninth almost feels like you're wasting his ability to get on base.

The return of Ronald Acuña Jr. is the ultimate wild card. If he slots back into that leadoff spot, it completely changes the complexion of the lineup. His speed and ability to get on base are electric, and it puts immediate pressure on the opposing pitcher. It could definitely lead to a surge in runs scored, but you're right, the pressure of expectations after his injury will be immense. How quickly he returns to his MVP form will be a huge factor.

And don't sleep on Drake Baldwin! That impressive minor league OBP is definitely intriguing. A catcher who can consistently get on base is a massive asset. If he can translate even a portion of that to the big leagues, it could be a real hidden gem that lengthens the lineup and provides crucial offense from a traditionally less offensive position.

If I were making lineup changes right now, I'd be tempted to put Profar in the leadoff spot to get that consistent on-base presence at the top, followed by Acuña when he returns. Then you can slot Olson in the heart of the order where he can really drive in runs. Baldwin hitting somewhere in the bottom third, but with a good OBP, could be a nice table-setter for the top of the order when it turns over.

Do I think the Braves can break into the top tier of offenses this season? Absolutely. The potential is there with the power of Olson, Riley, and Acuña (when healthy), combined with guys who can get on base like Albies and hopefully a productive Baldwin. If they can find the right lineup balance and everyone performs to their capabilities, they definitely have the firepower to be one of the highest-scoring teams in the league. It's going to be exciting to watch how it all unfolds, even from way over here!