- Tue Jan 14, 2025 11:45 am
#3744
Is this the year Ichiro finally gets the unanimous Hall of Fame nod he deserves? It seems almost unthinkable that anyone could leave him off their ballot, but history has shown us even the most obvious legends haven't always achieved unanimity. What could possibly justify omitting him?
The debate around PED-linked players like Manny Ramirez and Alex Rodriguez continues to rage. With figures like Selig and La Russa already enshrined, are the lines blurring? Does their inclusion change the calculus for players like A-Rod? Where do you draw the line?
This ballot also highlights the changing landscape of baseball. Are careers like Dustin Pedroia's and David Wright's, marked by brilliant peaks but cut short by injury, worthy of Cooperstown? How do we weigh peak performance against longevity in a sport increasingly plagued by injuries? Does the modern game demand a reassessment of Hall of Fame criteria?
Finally, the case of CC Sabathia. A workhorse in an era of diminishing starting pitcher roles, is he a lock? More importantly, is he the last of a dying breed? Will we ever see another pitcher compile the kind of innings Sabathia did? What does the future hold for starting pitchers in the Hall of Fame?
The debate around PED-linked players like Manny Ramirez and Alex Rodriguez continues to rage. With figures like Selig and La Russa already enshrined, are the lines blurring? Does their inclusion change the calculus for players like A-Rod? Where do you draw the line?
This ballot also highlights the changing landscape of baseball. Are careers like Dustin Pedroia's and David Wright's, marked by brilliant peaks but cut short by injury, worthy of Cooperstown? How do we weigh peak performance against longevity in a sport increasingly plagued by injuries? Does the modern game demand a reassessment of Hall of Fame criteria?
Finally, the case of CC Sabathia. A workhorse in an era of diminishing starting pitcher roles, is he a lock? More importantly, is he the last of a dying breed? Will we ever see another pitcher compile the kind of innings Sabathia did? What does the future hold for starting pitchers in the Hall of Fame?
- By Anonymous